AI Overview – Organic Ranking Overlap Dips Post Update | ResultFirst

Google AI Overview – Organic Ranking Overlap Dips Post Update

A couple of days ago, Google rolled out its Core March Update. The prime objective of this update was to enhance the quality of search results by delivering relevant content along with E-E-A-T experiences while shading low-quality content.

However, following this recent update, Google AI Overviews take another turn: it will probably cite pages that fall among the top 10 of the SERP. That means any content once ranked within the top 10 results is less likely to find a place in AI-generated results.

This change may impact content creators, SEO experts, and businesses that rely heavily on organic search visibility and traffic. With Google’s shift, it is clear that being in the top 10 isn’t enough anymore; you need to provide standard authority, structured content backed by credentials, original research, and clear signals of real-world expertise.

This could affect content creators, SEO professionals, and businesses whose input heavily depends on organic search visibility and traffic. With this change from Google, it is clear that a top 10 ranking is no longer enough. Your content must be well-structured, credential-backed original research, and real-world expertise insights.

The Organic Overlap Key Insights

In recent findings,

The number of AI Overview citations overlapping with the top 10 organic positions on Google decreased from 16% to 15% following the release of the core update in March 2025.

It may not seem like a lot on the surface, but much strategy goes behind that mere 1% shift in Google’s AI Overview for managing sources for AI-generated summaries.

Also, looking at the industry overview, this AI Overview is another new trend. AI Overviews refer to different sources, especially those that don’t fall into their top 10 organic positions.

Examples,

  • Travel Industry

Citation Increase: 12.9% to 19.5% (+6.6 percentage points)

This means that travel sites we have not seen after page one now have more chances of being cited in AI-generated answers.

  • Entertainment (Movies)

Citation Increase: 8.8% to 13.7% (+4.9 percentage points)

AI Overviews now prefer sites with rich media or not-so-well-known comments towards movies and streaming content.

  • Restaurants & Dining

Citation increase: 9.5% to 14.1% (+4.6 percentage points)

Local blogs, food influencers, and guides are now included in Google’s AI Overviews even when they’re not ranking on page one.

Why Does This Change Matter?

You might not know, but the Google AI overview appears in nearly half of all search results on Google and takes up to 48% of mobile screen space.

However, with this new AI overview change, AI-generated summaries may not cite the highest-ranked results from organic search unless the content is relevant and follows Google’s guidelines.

The decreasing overlap between the top 10 rankings and AI Overviews citations may not seem significant on paper, yet huge consequences play out in real life:

  • Visibility Is No Longer Just About Rankings

Traditional SEO mostly focused on ranking high on the first page. Now, pages outside the top 10 results of the SERP can occupy a place with AI-generated answers.

  • Organic Click-Through Rates Are Dropping

Organic Click-Through Rate is dropping with AI Overviews answering queries. This particularly impacts businesses relying on search engines for traffic and conversions.

  •  Minimal Website Traffic from AI Overviews

AI Overviews generate minimal website traffic, often resulting in very few or zero clicks. Even when they include links, the engagement is minimal compared to organic listings.

  • Google Is Citing Itself

Google AI Overviews is increasing the number of links in its AI-generated summaries. However, the links are not to other websites but rather to its search results. Google is now testing the link between AI overviews and new search queries on Google.com. This effectively closes the loop further, reducing referred traffic to external publishers.

For instance:

PFP SEO

The underlined links, which you can see with the 2025 Hyundai Ioniq 2025 and Kia EV6 in the text of the AI Overview, both at the top and in the middle section, take you back to a new Google Search. The smaller link icons take you to the side panel links, which go to publishers and external websites.

However, too many links confused users, as they were redirected to other Google Search pages on the same topic instead of linking to another source. Clearing the doubts, Google said,

To help people more easily explore topics and discover relevant websites, we’ve added links to some terms within AI Overviews when our systems determine it might be useful. Similar to our long-standing ‘People also search for’ feature, our testing shows that people find this helpful. AI Overviews continue to have prominent links out to the web, which we’re also expanding.

Moreover, John Mueller of Google said, “These [AI Overviews] are a part of search, and core updates affect search, so yes.” This statement means that AI overviews are now a part of the search experience, and changes will be made according to Google’s changing algorithms.

It’s Time To Adapt To A New Search Landscape

Jim Yu, founder and executive for BrightEdge, gives strategic insight into navigating these new AI overview changes.

1. Complementary Content Creation

Your primary article may not be able to rank on the first page or be included in the AI Overview; That’s why you must focus on creating complementary content that answers the next logical question(s). Follow-up questions have better chances of being cited, even if it’s not in the top 10 results of SERP.

Tips:

  • What is going to be the next logical question for the user?
  • Use tools such as AnswerThePublic, People Also Ask, or ChatGPT to get follow-up queries from them.
  • Make modular content-bundled blog pages, FAQ sections, or subpages targeting specific angles or details.

2. Optimize for Both Rankings and AI Citations

Do not force opposite choices between SEO and AI visibility; dual optimization is possible. Monitor your presence in both areas for a holistic view of your search visibility.

Tips:

  • Use structured data and schema markup to help Google parse your content clearly.
  • Include concise summaries that AI can easily extract.
  • Put well-formatted and concise answers to questions thoroughly raised at the beginning of your article.

3. Monitor AI Visibility in Isolation

Track all AI Overviews around you with the BrightEdge AI Overview Tracker, Semrush Sensor, SERPwatch, etc.

Metrics to Track:

  • Frequency of citing your pages by the AI Overviews.
  • Check whether it’s a main article or sourced from other related sub-content.
  • Click-through rate that AI elements get compared to traditional results.

4. Writing in AI Synthesis

Google’s AI demands pure and concise content baked in the relevant context.

Tips:

  • Use short sentences, clear paragraph structures or numbered lists, bullet lists, and subheadings.
  • Define terms and answer the question immediately. Supporting details follow after.

5. Review Underperforming Content

Remember that blog that is stuck on the second page? It could have that AI Overview potential now.

Plan of Action:

  • Update older posts with fresh data.
  • Add follow-up questions and answers.
  • Better formatting, which makes it more scannable for AI content.

AI Overviews: A New Competitive Arena

In addition, this brings a whole new competition:

  • AI models now judge you with a say in what is useful, relevant, and synthesizable.
  • Google is becoming more than just a neutral platform. It is increasingly transforming itself into a curator and publisher.
  • Relevance comes before rank as Google prioritizes beyond the first 10 pages with meaningful and diverse sites.
  • Usefulness of Content comes before Authority: Pages with lower authority may be cited if they serve the user intent sufficiently.
  • Towards the Zero-Click World: SERPS are changing from a gateway to an actual destination.

What to Expect?

Visibility is on its way into a new era that will impose a lot of dimensions:

Rankings are important, but clarity of structure, content focused on the question, and friendliness with AI matter too.

Google’s AI-adjusted answers may come with different interaction modes, including new multimodal content (images/videos) and personalization.

Expect to receive answers from Google as direct competition to traditional results.

Create Content That Ranks in Google AI Overviews With ResultFirst

With Google prioritizing quality over quantity, it’s time to create content that ranks in this AI-driven search landscape. Choose ResultFirst and optimize your content both for AI-overviews and traditional SEO. With years of experience delivering SEO services, we focus on E-E-A-T, modular content structures, schema integration, and AI-friendly formats to give your pages the best chance of being cited even if they dont rank in the top 10 results of the SERP.

Choose ResultFirst and enhance your visibility in AI-generated search results.

What to Read Next

ResultFirst is the ONLY SEO agency
you will ever need.

Our Pay for performance SEO programe helps companies
achieve impressive results